i think the major problem for WOE is participation My suggestion: Create a PUG (Pick Up Group) system where player with no guild can join as a temporary WOE guild under 1 flag when WOE period start. Let this guild join in the war between 2/3 usual establish guild to create some havoc and chaos. If these PUG can take castle, they may be reward as other winning guild. Advantage of PUG system: 1) Players in PUG may communicate and may interested to make better new guild compared to current PUG. 2) PUG guild may be benchmark to other established guild (current established guild should not lose to PUG guild) These may +1 guild each time WOE is on.